Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
http://hdl.handle.net/1942/40246
Title: | Gender-Based Ingroup Bias in the Application of Belgian Asylum Law | Authors: | VAES, Diego BIELEN, Samantha Grajzl, Peter |
Issue Date: | 2023 | Source: | 10th International Meeting in Law & Economics, University Paris Nanterre, 25-26/05/2023 | Abstract: | Impartiality is a central goal of the judiciary. However, a body of literature documented that judges often exhibit bias in decision-making. In the context of asylum adjudication, evidence of disparities in decision-making is also apparent. While the existing "refugee roulette" literature mainly focuses on the relationship between the judge's or the refugee's gender and the asylum decision, the impact of same-gender judge-refugee pairings on asylum appeal outcomes only received limited attention. This paper studies the existence of gender-based ingroup bias in Belgian asylum appeals by examining a novel dataset of 23,248 verdicts of the Belgian Council for Alien Law Litigation. Using a difference-indifference approach, we show that a judge-refugee gender match results in significantly higher chances for the refugee of receiving a favorable decision (about 35% from the mean value of a favorable decision for a refugee). In addition, we also provide evidence that ingroup bias is more pronounced in verdicts in which asylum authorities more strongly contest asylum narrative credibility, which we quantify by estimating a structural topic model, a state-of-the-art machine learning method. This paper is one of the first to examine gender-based ingroup bias in asylum appeals. This is a high-stakes context because of the direct and far-reaching consequences of the decision for the asylum seeker. The findings of positive gender-based ingroup bias are of direct interest to policymakers in creating awareness about the consequences of refugee-judge gender pairings within asylum courts. | Keywords: | Judicial bias;Gender;Ingroup bias;Asylum appeals | Document URI: | http://hdl.handle.net/1942/40246 | Category: | C2 | Type: | Conference Material |
Appears in Collections: | Research publications |
Files in This Item:
File | Description | Size | Format | |
---|---|---|---|---|
20230526_Abstract_IMLE2023_Paris.pdf | Conference material | 224.63 kB | Adobe PDF | View/Open |
Google ScholarTM
Check
Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.